Experience

A Recipe for Pleasure

How cooking can be a revelatory, gratifying source of joy.

What has five decades of food writing taught Ruth Reichl about pleasure? I emailed her to see if she’d tell me. “This is a subject that is very close to my heart,” the restaurant critic and cookbook author, who helmed Gourmet at the turn of the century, responded.

Her candor caught me off guard—but Reichl only writes things that are true. Her favorite review of
The Paris Novel—her 2024 book about a woman who, after a lifetime of denying herself enjoyment of any kind, gets a tiny taste of it, unlocking everything—said it was about “the transformative power of pleasure,” which was a revelation. “I’d never been able to articulate that belief, but it’s pretty much central to my life,” Reichl went on. “I genuinely think it’s one of the main things missing from modern life.” Later, on a video call, we continued the conversation.


“I grew up in an America that was virtually indifferent to food. One of the children’s books that really resonated with me, when I was around 7, was about Benjamin Franklin, who grew up in a family where they weren’t allowed to even mention food, because it was about pleasure. So at the table, you couldn’t say, ‘Oh, this is delicious.’

I thought, Here is this obvious source of great pleasure for many people. It is the easiest source of pleasure. It is one of the few sources of pleasure where you don’t have to feel guilty. It’s not sexual; it’s something you do for survival. It’s not even something that takes work: You can pick a perfect peach off a tree, and that’s enough to make you happy for the entire day. America’s basic principles are so puritanical. We didn’t allow ourselves this very basic, easy-to-access pleasure. It struck me as deeply wrong, even as a child.

What gets in the way of people experiencing pleasure? Guilt. Very small children have no problem with it: They do whatever feels good. But as we grow up, we’re taught to feel that if something gives you pleasure, if something is fun, there must be something wrong with it.

There is no greater pleasure than feeding people. Is there anything more fun than cooking something, putting it in front of people, and having them go, ‘Ahhhh!’? Cooking is a gift they open right in front of you. My husband is always saying, ‘Stop watching me eat!’

People ask me, ‘What’s your favorite thing to cook?’ And I think, Well, who am I cooking for? When I have a dinner party, I decide what I’m going to make depending on what those people like. If you pay attention to what people’s tastes are, you get to know a lot about them. They’re telling you without knowing it.

I’ll never forget the first time I went to Yorkville with my father [who came to this country when he was 26]. I’d never thought of him as German. I never knew he had a heavy German accent. He just sounded like my father.

But there we are, in Schaller & Weber, and suddenly my father is a different person to me. He’s a person who is speaking German, to the butcher, and talking about foods we never ate at our house. He wanted kasseler rippchen. And I suddenly saw that walking into that butcher shop was, for him, a way of going home.

I’ve always loved markets. It’s such a joy to me that H-Mart is all over New York now. There’s one that opened a couple years ago in my neighborhood, and I can go in there and watch people walking the aisles, picking things. I probably make a nuisance of myself, trailing behind them.

Food choices are a lot like handwriting. They are a way we choose to present ourselves to the world. Some restaurant critics tell people what to order. I never did that. I always said, ‘You can order anything you want. You just can’t order anything that anybody else has ordered.’ But I could almost always guess what people were going to get.

For instance, I had one friend I took out a lot in L.A. who was the youngest of six children. She always ordered the most expensive thing on the menu because, when she was a kid, she was never allowed to do that. She didn’t care what it was. That told you something about her: having the most expensive thing was more important to her than liking it.

I have friends who will order the weirdest dish on the menu. What they’re saying is, ‘I am adventurous. I am fearless. And yes, I am going to eat the slugs with ant sauce.’

I believe a lot of vegetarianism is performative. I mean, a lot of people are vegetarian for very good reasons, but a lot of people are vegetarian for reasons that essentially say, ‘I am a good person. I do not eat living creatures.’ Especially those who say, ‘I don’t eat anything with a face.’ I’ve taken a lot of people like that out, and somehow, they don’t think fish have faces.

People who order a lot of sweet things usually turn out to be people who no longer drink. I don’t think they know they’re giving themselves away. ‘I want three desserts.’ I think, Ah—you’re really missing your alcohol.

The first story I ever read in Gourmet, by Robert P. Tristram Coffin, was about a night he and a friend spent with a Maine lobsterman. It was a revelation, a kind of a fairy tale. He was describing real things, but in language that made them seem otherworldly. The way he wrote about the moon on the water, going to this island in the middle of the night, the big bonfire, cracking those lobsters…. It was really magical.

I still really believe that everybody’s life is interesting and that fascinating things happen every day. Which goes to the whole idea of paying attention to what’s available to you, which gets back to pleasure. If you go outside and you say, ‘Oh, the sky is blue and the sun is shining,’ that can be a source of enormous pleasure if you allow it to, especially after a horrible snowstorm. A horrible snowstorm is gorgeous, too, if you give yourself to it.

Part of how I came to see things that way has to do with having had a bipolar mother. Because it took so little to make my mother unhappy, I wanted the other side of the coin. If [her condition] was about being unhappy for reasons you can’t control, how do you be happy for reasons you can control? Where do you find sources of happiness?

When I was first doing Twitter [after Condé Nast closed Gourmet, in 2009], I wrote what people called ‘haikus.’ One of the things I loved about that was, every day, I found myself looking for little moments of pleasure. One day I’m in the kitchen and I look up, and there’s this scarlet bird that just flashes past the window. And it made me so happy. I am sorry that Twitter has started being something that you can’t use anymore. But it was a nice interlude in my life.”


This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity.